Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] You're listening to the ASOTU CON Sessions by Effectv, live from ASOTU CON 2024. My name is Joe Overby, and I'm here on the ASOTU CON podcast stage in collaboration with Effect TV. 0:16 And sitting across from me is Robert Hollenshead, Chris Bell, and Brian Kramer. They're all part of the, uh, Accu-Trade team at Cars Commerce. Guys, thank y'all so much for... Whoops. 0:25 Thank y'all so much for- You're good... being here today. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Absolutely. Well, um, so I wanna... 0:31 We're, we're gonna talk a little bit about used car acquisition, but I, I wanna go back to something Kyle mentioned during a, uh, general session this morning. He said, "Sales strategy is actually the purchase strategy." 0:43 So, um, how do you guys see that playing out in the used car market? Purchase strategy? Yeah. How... 0:50 So if sales strategy is actually the purchase strategy, so essentially, you know, you, you make your money at the time of purchase. How do you see that playing out in the used car market? 1:00 Well, if you're talking about a trade-in, it's obvious, you know, uh, you got an opportunity to make a profit on a car [chuckles] when you trade it correctly. Right. 1:07 Uh, if you, uh, aren't sure what you have, it's very difficult to trade it properly, right? Yeah. So... And I, [clears throat] I would add to that, if you're the best end user, 1:17 retail-wise, it's gonna be i- a lot easier to make you the best end user when it comes to acquisition. 1:22 So if you know the exit strategy, or if you know if you're not the best end user, who that best, who that best end user is, then you're gonna be able to acquire more vehicles. Right. Well, um, you know, obviously, the... 1:37 For so many years, the way dealers acquired used cars was, was through auto auctions. And, you know, that, that market has, has changed. It's become more digital. 1:46 But it's still a, a big, big presence in [clears throat] wholesale. So, how do you guys see the used, the future of the used car auto auction? 1:55 Well, I, I'm sure there's a whole bunch of people would think that it's, like, got a limited future. I, I'm personally 100% in a different belief of that. 2:04 I think as long as there's people breathing air, there's gonna be car auctions. 2:07 In other words, without a car auction, you don't have instant liquidity, regardless of whether it's a digital circumstance or an in-lane circumstance or whether it's all digital and simulcast. 2:17 Um, the volume has not gone down, and it's not gonna be going down anytime soon. It's the only place you're gonna be able to find a check instantly in the next 30 seconds. You follow me? Yeah. 2:26 Uh, more importantly, uh, when cars are all aggregated in one place at one time, the probability you're gonna find the cars that you want when you're wasting your time looking for cars is much higher, which is one of the main reasons why we use critical mass when we're selling cars at an auction block. 2:39 We don't confuse people looking at F-250s and Volkswagen diesels simultaneously. You wanna look at a Mercedes-Benz tomorrow morning, uh, you're gonna look at 100 of them in one place at one time. 2:49 If they're all getting sold, the, the probability that more eyeballs are looking at your car, and you're gonna get a higher, uh, return. 2:56 A- and if the buyers know they can trust the seller, and every car is getting sold, you're gonna maintain their attention. Yeah, I think- That's just a fact. 3:02 Well, and it speaks to just kind of the way people shop in general. I mean, that's why you see all these pop-up marketplaces for, you know, vintage good sales. 3:11 They're all together in one place 'cause you know- It's, it's what we've been doing at the auction- Yeah... for many, many, many decades. Yes. You follow me? That ain't going away anytime soon. That I can promise you. 3:20 Yeah. So, you know, regardless of whether you're buying a car at an auction or, you know, taking the trade-in from consumer or, you know, buying from, from, from another dealer, um, you've gotta appraise the car. 3:33 So for an electric vehicle, how does that appraisal strategy differ? What are some of the unique implications and, and strategies involved with that? 3:42 [chuckles] Once again, I think that's got a lot to do with if you're, uh, the best or the perceived best end user of a car. 3:49 If you're a Mercedes dealer right now, and, I mean, EVs are stacked up on your lot, you think you're really looking to trade them cars for too much money? Right. 3:55 No, you're looking for another best end user, someplace you can exhaust that car instantaneously, uh, uh, to get it out of your inventory. You see what I'm saying to you? Mm-hmm. Um, a- and I think if you... 4:05 That's one example, but if you look across the board, um, um... Let's say we're gonna sell 50 EVs tomorrow. We're not gonna sell one of those EVs to the brand-specific dealer. 4:16 If it's a Ford EV, it's not going to a Ford dealer. If it's a, a, a Audi e-tron, it's not going to an Audi dealer. That's where they came from. You see what I'm saying to you? 4:25 So being a, uh, let's call it a, a liquidator, in other words, somebody that's in the business of remarketing those cars, right? 4:32 We absorb them, put them together in a more logical place where the dealer is happy to take our check because they need to make it disappear. 4:39 They don't need more of them when the new ones are stacking up, and they can't give them away. You follow me? Mm-hmm. Uh, uh, and I think that's, uh, pretty much in a nutshell what it would be. 4:48 A, a dealer that doesn't have an exit strategy on EVs right now, I think they're even... 4:53 That's actually, if I'm not mistaken, the, the people that are using Accu-Trade, um, that's really the cars that we're actually picking off, a Volkswagen, uh, electric something in San Francisco. Yep. 5:03 Uh, some who knows what from... And it's a brand-specific dealer. It's coming from Volkswagen dealers. 5:08 It's coming from an Audi dealer 'cause they don't have any interest in it, and they don't have a, a, a way to actually liquidate. So... So, [clears throat] Brian, Chris, what are your thoughts on that? Go ahead. 5:20 Well, you know, [clears throat] obviously, when I look at electric cars, I look at it this way. There's Tesla, and there's the rest of them, right? Tesla sets the bar on the market, lowers the price. 5:33 Obviously, other, other folks are forced to follow suit. Um, the- And they're sellable, Chrissy. They're absolutely sellable. In other words, if we have 80 Teslas tomorrow to sell, they're all getting sold. 5:45 You understand what I'm saying? But when you got a BMW something- Stuff... and there's... It's, it's a whole different ballgame. Hey- Teslas are totally remarketable, so you can predict the price. 5:55 You see what I'm saying? The only place you're ever gonna find that out to your first question is at an auction. Yeah, and the- Most dealers depend on that. 6:00 I mean, if you look at auction volume numbers for EVs, it's dominated by Tesla.Right. I wanna add one thing. Sure. Um, you know, the other part of the EV thing is obviously price point. 6:12 The more expensive they get, I mean, it, it gets very... I mean, Tesla with their Plaid and things like that, you start getting up over a hundred thousand. 6:19 You see it with the Hummers, you see it with the, some of the Mercedes EVs, the BMWs. They're very difficult to, uh, to sell, um, both in an auction format and obviously retail. Lease programs. 6:31 Lease programs are strong, with the money back strong, uh, the, the federal money. And, you know, if you could be in a car for four or five hundred dollars less a month than purchasing a used one. 6:42 An under twenty-five thousand dollar EV. Yes. What's the, [chuckles] what's the sell rate on those? I believe it's a hundred percent. So to, uh, to shift gears a little bit, um, 6:54 why or I guess, how are dealers utilizing technology when it comes to appraising used cars? Well, [clears throat] I would say that they're not all, uh, using it the same way. Yeah. 7:06 I would say that some, a lot of dealers are leveraging it, leveraging it very well. I see dealers that have... 7:12 Well, we're gonna be, uh, with Joel Bassam, who's got, you know, sixty, seventy sales, you know, associates that are appraising cars at scale, uh, two thirty today. But I also see- Wow... 7:22 uh, a lot of Toyota dealerships that have fifty or more people appraising cars. 7:26 So we see this transition of them leveraging, empowering the salespeople with, with an app to do at least the first eighty, eighty-five percent, if not a hundred percent of the, of the appraisal, in order to move the deal forward, to remove the friction from appraising the car. 7:38 'Cause we see a lot of drop trades from when a lead was submitted on cars.com to when it actually transacted. 7:44 And we think that a big reason of that friction is because of the amount of effort it takes in order to appraise a vehicle. 7:49 So the easier you make it to appraise a car faster, to be able to then push it into whatever platform you want, CRM you wanna, uh, take it from there. 7:56 But i-in order to appraise a car accurately using, you know, their values, uh, that are accurate and they're guaranteed with a check, I think that's the key, is to be able to do that in three minutes or less. 8:06 There's, I don't know, um, if there's another solution that can do that. So just to add to that, and it's really, I think, the most important part is about transparency. Do you see what I'm saying? Mm-hmm. 8:16 Inclusion of the people in the dealership, where they're actually included, a salesperson's actually included in it, where they have rational, fact-based, premise-based, uh, items i-i-in the appraisal. 8:28 You understand the picture, the dent, the scratch. But if they're included in that, it makes it much easier to tell the McGillicuddy why their car is worth what it's worth. You understand? Yeah. 8:36 And a McGillicuddy does not wanna know. He's been in the business thirty years. He knows what he's talking about. No, they wanna see rationally. Bing, bang, boom, bang, doop. And therefore, that's what it is. 8:46 You see what I'm saying? So dealers that we actually have using it, not just in the sales floor, but in the, in the service drive, there's no question that they're, uh, not... Forget their ROI. 8:57 The, the, I would call it the transparency, not just with the consumer, but with the sales force as well. Yeah. You see what I'm saying, Joe? 9:04 If you've ever been in a dealership and the salesperson goes, gives the used car manager, "Go appraise my car," he's back there being best friends for life with the, with the customer. 9:13 They're almost, they're almost relatives. You wear plaid, I wear plaid. You, you understand what I'm saying? Yeah. We could be related. "Let me go see what the used car manager's gonna give us for your car. 9:23 I'm sure it'll be a great number." Comes back two seconds later, bounces out of the desk. Customer doesn't have anything other than a number. How do you rationalize that? You understand what I'm saying? Yeah. 9:33 Quarter panel's replaced. The OBD says that it said, "Whoa." You understand? All of a sudden, you got rational conversation. 9:40 This is, without any question or doubt, not just useful for the consumer, but for the salesperson not to sit there fumbling and bumbling what they're talking about. 9:49 And then the communication with the sales desk, with the, with the, with the appraiser. You see what I'm saying to you? That whole thing is congruent. 9:57 And it, it's the exact same thing happens when, Brian, when you got dealerships doing, uh, a hundred appraisals in a service drive, and they're picking off a hundred, 10:07 hundred cars a month that they otherwise picked up two a month because we're actually using no transportation. We're talking about auctions or transportation fees. What are the... No. 10:17 Service drive, we already got the customer there. Those cars- And those deals have low market day supply. Yeah. Well- Low days on market. Wait, Joe. Joe, wait, you're missing this. And this car has pedigree. 10:26 You ever hear the word pedigree? Mm-hmm. Not a horse. I'm talking about a car. Right. We know the VIN, we know the miles, we know the, we know when it was an oil change was last. 10:33 We got the pictures from to six months ago when the car was in for the oil change. 10:36 So in other words, now when you leverage that, when you acquire that unit, put them in a new car 'cause you can lease them a new one for seven hundred dollars less than the payment that the car and I've got it. 10:44 In other words, now when you put that car, after you put it back through oil change, certified, boom, you can now tell the next McGillicuddy, "We knew who bought this car new. 10:53 It wasn't an Ir- a Avis, Hertz, Sixt rental car that we put a pinstripe on, now it's no longer a junk." You understand? No, this car, we sold it new. Our neighbor sold it new. We pinched it out of the service drive. 11:07 You see what I'm saying to you? The, it's not just a, a, a one, uh, pixel. 11:12 It's, it's many pixels that make up the picture of when you're asking a question about technology and how you leverage it and how you increase the transparency. Yeah. Does that make sense to you, pal? Mm-hmm. 11:23 Well, we've, we've got, uh, just a, just a minute left here in our, in our conversation, so I wanted it to close on this. Why have, 11:31 why has acquiring used cars from consumers, the, the McGillicuddys, why has that become so important? How does the approach, you know, differ than acquiring a car from a dealer? 11:44 So you're serious with that question, right? Yeah, yeah. [laughs] Okay. So, so when a car comes out of somebody's garage, and that's where it's been parked for the last year and a half- Right... 11:53 is that different than the one that was already at the auction three different times? And- Right... in other words, and the rug was fixed and the other thing was said, and you're gonna sell that to your sister? No. 12:02 Or would you pick the one that you pinched from- Yeah... the consumer? You see? That is, "Hey, don't touch that. Uh, you didn't buy it yet." Uh, and they'reWiping thing. 12:12 You, you understand it's a different pedigree of a vehicle. It makes it much easier. It doesn't smell like an old cigar. You understand? It's different. It's, it's like a different circumstance. It makes it much easier. 12:23 It's like eating chicken salad or what? Chicken- I don't... Are we allowed to say it? [laughs] I am. But I know chicken poop ain't the same as chicken salad. [laughs] Right. 12:32 And that's one that's been through the used car factory four times as opposed to one that just popped out of the garage, by the way, with four sets of keys. Yeah. You see what I'm saying? Yeah. 12:41 The one that's been through the used car factory never has more than one. Don't mean nothing until you try to make the delivery, does it? Yeah. You see what I'm saying? But the challenge, the challenge for dealers is 12:50 unless you're doing the whole active trade appraisal with the client present, walking around, building a condition report, you're just looking at an average number of average. 12:59 Then the dealers are at a distinct disadvantage. 13:01 They're putting too much into the cars that are, that are not that way, that have le- less pedigree, and they're putting not enough in the cars that have the right pedigrees. So you- And that's it all the time. 13:10 So you're missing the good ones and you're getting the bad ones. Yeah. It's kind of like a sell it to the bottom type thing. You understand what I'm saying? Yeah. Yeah. 13:17 When, when you do that, you never have one for the 45-degree angle out on the point, do you? [laughs] Yeah. You see what I'm saying? Yeah. Yeah. Well, guys, we'll have to leave it there for today. 13:26 Thank y'all so much for joining us. Let's give these gentlemen a round of applause. [upbeat music] Thank you for listening to this ASSOTU Con session by Effective. 13:34 If you want more content like this, you can check out our other podcasts. 13:37 We have a daily show called The Automotive Troublemaker, Monday through Friday, here on podcasts, also live streamed on YouTube and LinkedIn and Facebook. 13:45 We also have a long form podcast called Auto Collabs, Auto Collabs. And if you just wanna go a little deeper into this community, you should sign up for our regular email. We put our heart and soul into it. 13:56 You can get it for free by going to assotu.com. We'll see you next time. [upbeat music]