Transcript 0:00 This is In the Dirt with Isotu. [car revving] This is how you have a conversation at the NADA Show. Come on. You all, our friends at TrueCar know how to do it right. Alan, thanks for joining us. 0:12 Matt Jones, thanks for joining us again. Always fun to have you here. Absolutely. And, uh, just hopefully we lay back a little bit- All right... and talk about what we see. 0:19 You all have a unique perspective on the industry, um, that a lot of us don't have, so how we can share some of those perspective to help dealers make some better decisions. So thanks for being here with us. Absolutely. 0:28 Pleasure. Alan, why don't you? You've been in the business a little bit longer than me, why don't you start? Just an introduction, or what do you wanna- Yeah. Yeah. Hit 'em with it. Hit 'em with it. 0:34 Who are you and what do you do? Yeah. I head up business development for, for TrueCar. I, I've been in this business all of my adult life. 0:42 I started in a dealership, and I, I'll tell you how long ago it's been, I sold Geos, brand new Geos. Yo. Geo Metro. That's right. [laughs] Those are cars you look like you can flip it over. You can flip 'em. 0:52 I- Matt, I wanna see Matt get in a Geo Metro... I, I would try to squat a Geo. He would squat it. [laughs] He wouldn't get in it. He'd just be like, "I'm not getting in that piece of-" He'd get in it- Right... 0:59 punch his feet through the floor and then pick it up. [laughs] Fred Flintstone style. Look, trying to sa- be effective with money. There you go. I love it. 1:05 So I, I sold new and used, I did F&I and aftermarket, and then I got into the finance end of it. Worked in, uh, in non-prime auto finance for a number of years. 1:14 And, and ultimately found myself at TrueCar, and I feel, where we are in the, in the industry, it's such an interesting time. 1:22 It's just we've seen so much change, and, uh, just in the last three or four years, than lots of people might see in their entire career. It's just real exciting. Isn't that wild? 1:32 I mean, you, like, for you being in the industry 30-plus years saying, "I've seen a lot of change." 1:37 I mean, you went through recessions and you've been through all of it, and just to say, like, the last three or four years has been a ton of change, that's- that's a big statement I feel like. You know? It really is. 1:46 It's really starting to accelerate. And, a- and I think that, um, understanding where we're headed is more challenging now than it ever has been. You can't just draw the line out and see exactly where we're gonna be. 2:00 Yeah, that's... Yeah. I've, I've only been in the business for 20 years, or 22. Right? Only. Only. Right. [laughs] That's like a lifetime, but it's only 22 years. This business moves quick. Yeah. 2:08 And, and I think of the, the business with all the change we're talking, it's like our industry is, like, in puberty. Like, this is like a rough time. 2:14 Like, we're, we're learning, we're growing, but we're about to hit a growth spurt. 2:18 You know, we had a very interesting past three years that are gonna really impact the rest of our trajectory as an industry, kind of like how that does as we're growing as humans. I always like to compare this to humans. 2:27 That's a really interesting metaphor- But-... because if you think about it- Yeah... you, you kinda come, you grow up and you realize, you kinda feel like you know who you are. Yes. Right. Right? Right. 2:36 And then everything starts to change, and then you're like, "Who am I?" Yes. And then you get through that and you realize, "This is who I really am." This is who I really am. Yeah. 2:42 You know- And I think as an industry, that's where we're headed to... 2:44 that's so interesting because like Paul and I were talking, and we said, like, think- think back to let's go five, seven years ago, back in, like, even at NADA or at a, at any other, the trade shows or online, and we're talking digital retailing, we're talking attribution. 3:01 We're talking we're gonna be shut down because of autonomous driving- Right... and because of ride sharing. Dude, that was the conversation. Right? That was the conversation like five years ago. 3:09 And, and there was, there was this... And now some of that stuff is almost like you don't even hear it at the show. Right. Right. You know what the big one was? It's like it doesn't even exist anymore. Don't. 3:17 The big one was millennials aren't gonna buy cars. Right. [laughs] No. Yeah. And they don't want- They're the largest buying demographic. Right. Right. Major. It's wild. Major. Car sharing, it... 3:27 I wish, I wish we could, like, roll back and just listen to f- There was doomsday- Yeah... being preached at NADA five years ago. What are we gonna do? It's gonna be about cost per mile and not about vehicle ownership. 3:39 Well, you know, maybe for, maybe for 1.5% of the buyers out there it is. But for everybody else- Right... right, this is very similar. 3:47 It's different, but similar to what it has been, but just more grown, more, more tools, more resources, like a person who is actually hitting their stride. And that's how I think of that change is really put it... 3:58 I mean, none of us are gonna say that online shopping is not gonna be a fixture in automotive. Right. We all know that it's gonna be. It- It's a, so it is a part of who we are going forward. Yeah. 4:07 That's what I'm saying, like these changes have been made. Yeah. I think it's an interesting time. Really looking forward to 2023, 'cause I think we're gonna get back to some normality that we're kind of used to. 4:15 Hopefully lots of cars, hopefully lots of transactions, hopefully a lot of shopping in person, online. So I'm incredibly excited about where, uh, the future lies for H1 and H2. I think this is a really fun time. 4:25 I think so, too. Yeah. I, so you all have a perspective because you, you get to see so much data, right? That everyone doesn't. Like, certain dealers and regions can see what they have, right? 4:36 And there's a lot of conversation around first-party data and seeing your own, understanding your own stuff. But if you zoom out a little bit, you can see some macro trends across the country and in regions. 4:45 Is there anything you can share with us about some of those things you're seeing that maybe dealers can take as a little bit of, uh, as an advisement to just even start thinking about, you know, the way they're doing things? 4:56 There's an emerging group of shoppers, and we've seen this in our industry. We had people who came in that were price shoppers. We know how to sell them. They come in, they're payment shoppers. 5:07 Well, we know how to work that type of deal. There's this new generation of shopper that indexes on the process. I'm not sure what I wanna buy- Ah... but I know how I wanna buy it. Ah, interesting. 5:19 And, and they will be, they will start making exclusions at the top of their consideration to say- Based on the process, did you say? The process... b- based on what options do I have? When do I need to engage? 5:30 How much can I do on my own? What happens when I raise my hand and need help? Who's there to help me, and what do they want me to do? 5:36 That's the, that's the, the, the thing that we're seeing em- emerge, and we see it in other verticals, right? We, we know. We, you, you see a product that you're really interested in. 5:46 You see it in your feed or a friend tells you about it. Yep. But you go to Amazon and put in the name of the product. There it is. Why? 'Cause you, you a process shopper. That's the, that's the shopper. 5:53 That's how you're thinking about how you wanna purchase. Put it in. If they have it, I do this, I do this, I get it. Right. Yep. Yeah. 5:58 That's, that's a big, that's a, that's a really interesting point because, um, I think what's interesting is, like, we went-Initially as an industry to, uh, you know, price and payment is all about whether or not I can, I can, like, just show something s- to someone, and so there's a lot of, like, technology, there's a lot of efficiency involved in whether or not that happens, get your price online. 6:21 And then we went, "Okay, now I, I see that there's, like, a whole, there's a whole nother ecosystem of a process that has to be involved." 6:30 But what I think is when I, when I'm hearing that, when I'm hearing you say this, is like, the closer... The further we get from technology and we go to process, the closer we're actually getting to people, right? 6:42 And it's like, not just how I wanna buy, but who I'm gonna buy from. 6:47 And, you know, o- one of the, uh, one of the really cool things that, that TrueCar has done recently, you kind of did this, like, you know, getting into the community, giving back and, and I think that you're... 6:58 Uh, like a couple things that, that Matt has told us about of like getting back to the community and TrueCar actually doing that, kind of paving a road for- Yeah... 7:05 dealers to do the same, because I think the next step for people is probably going from, "Oh, that's how I wanna buy," to "That's who I wanna buy from," right? Right. 7:14 And, and in, in a space where there's 60,000 dealers, is that about right? If you talk about franchise Including independents too. Right? Yeah. Yeah. 7:22 It really is gonna come down to quite often process, who's gonna give it to me the way that I want, and who do I wanna engage with and for what reasons, you know? There are companies that we've all... 7:30 We're all consumers, right? Right. Everybody who's watching this is a consumer, and all of us have chosen to do business or opt to not do business with somebody for whatever particular reason, right? 7:39 So when we think about our own experiences as human beings, and we put that into a, you know, a public company's experience and how we wanna meet our consumers, yeah, we wanna help people understand what we all say in the car business, "People buy from people." 7:50 Yeah. People buy from people that they like, right? Yep. 7:52 So we wanna lead the charge by being out there and showing all of these different demographics that are sometimes overlooked in, you know, popular advertising, popular media. We wanna make sure that they have a voice. 8:02 We wanna make sure that they're looked at and talked to. And hopefully, 8:06 we already know that our dealers are the pillars of communities, but also more dealers will chip in and more dealers will follow suit and be just a, you know, a good steward. 8:13 It's not just because it's the right thing to do, but it's also makes good business sense. Yeah. You know? Absolutely. 8:18 My son played baseball in high school, and if I saw an advertisement from a dealership on my son's baseball field, well, guess where I'm probably gonna put on my considerations. That's right. Absolutely. 8:29 So we have to con- Jesus. What is it? Love people more than you love cars. More than you love cars. 8:32 So a- as our company becomes more, uh, comfortable with that term, we always have been, but we're looking to, um, to kind of lead the way from a, from a corporate responsibility standpoint. Yeah. 8:43 We're people first, and that's why h- this process conversation is so important because it's more than numbers, it's more than price, it's more than payment. 8:51 People have a way that they wanna get down, and if they're process-driven, I think we've been tool-driven. Ah. Right? Yeah. But maybe we need to start looking more- Who is... Uh, we were talking to a dealer yesterday 9:04 and, and he, he said something and we kind of latched onto it. And he says, "It's time for our technology to serve our process and not our process serving our technology." 9:15 And that kind of like resonated with us real quick. Right. 9:17 And because when you look back, you know, we were talking about NADA five years ago, but you look as technology's, you know, been on the upswing as far as its deployment in just about every step of dealership life, kind of the, the appeal of it is that the technology's gonna fix a problem. 9:33 And so plugging it in or, or getting a hammer and pounding it into a spot because, you know, like, at first glance, it looks like it belongs there. Yeah. 9:41 But not considering what that does to the rest of the process- Right... has got us in this place, like you said, like we've gone through this puberty stage, and now we're trying to figure out who we really are. Yeah. 9:49 And I think the conversation has always been circling back to this, back to this like, "Oh, the process is the closest to what the pe- where the person actually is." 9:58 Te- technology should hide the complexity and not produce the complexity. I love that. [whistles] And think about the things we- Come on, now... we buy and how we buy them. 10:08 I don't know the first thing of how those packages show up at my door. Right. [laughs] You're like, "They get, I'm king." The magic Amazon Oompa-Loompas. Yeah. [laughs] Right? 10:18 But if you have, if you have a trusted experience and trusted stakeholders in the experience, then as a consumer, it frees you to focus on the things that you really- Absolutely... care about and what really- Yeah... 10:31 interests you, and you don't worry about that part of it. Yeah. 10:34 We have, um, at our studios in Syracuse, a visual effects artist just moved to Syracuse, and he, he did v- led visual effects on, like, Lord of the Rings, and he developed the, the 3D panel technology behind The Mandalorian and all the way Disney's shooting. 10:49 And he came in and he talked to our group, and what he said, we were... He, he shows his highlight reel, right? And it's just like everything from like The Matrix to Lord of the Rings and all these shots. 10:58 We're like, "That was you? That was you?" And he said this. He goes, "Oh, my best work is the work you've never seen." To your point. Oh. Yeah. And I was like, "Ah, I see what you're saying there." 11:08 [laughs] That's unbelievable. I see what you're saying there. Yeah. And so that really does tie in with the fact when the technology's good enough, you don't even notice it's there. Oh, that's, that's incredible. Yeah. 11:16 Yeah. I, I love it though. Yeah, I don't know how that process works either. When I, when I need some new lotion... I said lotion 'cause I'm feeling kind of ashy right now. No, everybody is at, at NADA. 11:23 You know, because, you know, we, we're, we're getting dried out a little bit. We're all dry. You're gonna start seeing a lot of ChapStick lips tomorrow. Yeah, yeah. By tomorrow, it's over. But you know, that's... 11:29 But yeah, it's the process that makes me, that, that drives me. It's not that I don't necessarily wanna go to Vons, right? 11:33 It's not that I don't wanna do this, but I like the process, and there's other online ven- But I like the process, and I don't... Yeah, it's just there. And it's, uh, it's invisible. Yeah. I like that a lot. 11:44 So just, like, do me a favor. Encourage some dealers. What, what, what would you encourage people with in this next year? 11:51 Because all of this, like, change and change has been happening, and, like, you've been on the franchise side and the, and the, the, the vendor side and the partner side. What do you... 12:02 Like, what are you charging dealers with right now- This is gonna sound crazy... in the, in the light of that?Have the courage to doubt yourself. Have the courage, right- Someone put that on a shirt, y'all. 12:14 [laughs] Have the courage- Wow... to consider that- Wow [laughs]... everything that you've accumulated- Wow. [laughs] Wow. [laughs]... up to this point- Someone say a thing... might be no longer valid. Yeah. Wow. 12:28 As, as, as the situation changes, as our industry evolves, things that we believe... I'll tell you a real quick story. And- I love stories... date myself again. I sold- I'm, at this point, I'm like, "When the fuck?" 12:40 [laughs] I know. [laughs] So I sold, I, I sold, uh, Chevys and Geos and, and Hyundais at my first dealership, and we used to get program cars from the rental car companies. We got a big shipment of Chevy Corsicas. 12:53 Again, this was back in the day. I love this. It brings me all... [laughs] I could actually smell what a Corsica smells like right now. Yes. Yeah, you can. You know exactly what I mean. So I get a phone up, 13:03 and the guy says, "Hey, I was driving past the lot. I saw this gray-green one in a... What, w- what can I buy that car for?" And I'm green piece salesperson. I'm two months in the business. I get all excited. 13:13 I put the phone down. I run over to the tower. I'm like, "I think this guy's really interested. He's on the Corsica out there on the point, and he wants to know what he can buy it for." 13:20 My sales manager looks down his glasses. You know the look? [laughs] Oh, yeah. Like this. "We don't give out prices over the phone. 13:29 If he wants to buy the car, he can come down here, and I'll tell him what he can buy it for." He would not recognize our business right now. 13:38 [laughs] But what he knew at that time, "No, sir, we don't sell cars over the phone." Yeah. That was a article of faith- Yes... at that time. Yep. Right. So here's the thing. 13:48 What are the things that the four of us believe are articles of faith right now- Whoa... that a year from now we're gonna look back and, and, and say to ourselves, "Man, you remember when we thought-" [laughs] 13:56 Have courage- "... millennials weren't gonna buy cars?"... to doubt yourself. So good. He gone. [laughs] He gone. It's too much for one. It's too mu- too much for one. Yeah. Too much for one 15-minute setting. 14:06 Man, Alan, Matt- And don't look at me. There's nothing I'm gonna say after that. I saw you, like, winding up and be like, "Nah." Nope. Nope. That was it. Nope. Nope. Nope. That's it. That's it. 14:14 What, yeah, what are we gonna put a bow on that? No, there's nothing. Man. Nothing. That, it's just been fun. Nothing. Have the courage to doubt yourself. I can't, I can't wrap that any better. 14:21 Alan, Matt, thanks for hanging out with us. Oh, thank you. This has been great, guys. Thanks for dealing with us. I really appreciate the- You guys are rock stars. 14:26 Thank you for everything that you're doing, and thank you for the time here. [upbeat music] Thank you for listening to In the Dirt with ASOTU. 14:32 We love the automotive industry and the people who make it run day in and day out. We would love to connect with you more through our daily dose of fun, a free email that you can sign up for at asotu.com. 14:42 That's A-S-O-T-U dot com. We put our heart and soul into it every day. Thanks again for listening. Join us next time for more conversations In the Dirt with ASOTU.