The 10-Second Version (AI Summary)
What happened: CarMax CEO Keith Barr is adopting Carvana-style recon, logistics and financing while keeping CarMax's in-person stores.
Why it matters: The two giants hold less than 10% of a roughly $550 billion used retail market, and both want more.
What to do: Tighten your lender relationships and keep recon from becoming your used-car bottleneck.
AI-generated summary, reviewed by the ASOTU team.
Would a seven-day return policy replace your test drive?
We broke this down on episode #1502 of the Automotive State of the Union podcast.
One of our team members had the luxury of test driving his last car before he bought it. Plenty of shoppers won't make that trip. For them, a seven-day, any-reason return policy might be the thing that seals the deal. How franchise dealers compete for that shopper's attention is one of the most interesting questions in used cars right now.
How is CarMax responding to Carvana's push for the used-car crown?
About 20 million used cars sell at retail in the U.S. each year, a market worth roughly $550 billion according to Cox Automotive. CarMax and Carvana hold less than 10% of it combined. On its earnings call last month, Carvana CEO Ernie Garcia III said his company is close to becoming the nation's largest used-car retailer, The Wall Street Journal reports.
CarMax has been heading the other direction. Its sales fell from 924,000 units in the fiscal year ended February 2022 to 766,000 two years later, a drop of about 17%. The company parted ways with CEO Bill Nash in 2025 and hired Keith Barr, a hotel industry veteran from IHG with no automotive experience. It has also run three rounds of layoffs in about a year.
Barr is keeping the stores, and his plan borrows heavily from Carvana's back end:
CarMax | Carvana | |
|---|---|---|
Footprint | 260 dealerships plus online sales | Online-first; vending towers deliver cars ordered online |
Test drive | In-store test drives | Seven-day, any-reason return |
Reconditioning | Mostly store service bays on paper; moving to software-driven recon and more standalone sites (first opened in 2024) | Dozens of assembly-line-style sites; in-house software since 2023 |
Logistics | Decentralized stores moving toward hub-and-spoke | Hub-and-spoke network |
Financing | Expanding in-house lending, especially to mid-tier credit | Finances about 85% of its own sales, then sells the loans |
"Customers, even though they say they're digital, the truth is the vast majority of them are still going to a store to test drive."
Where should franchise dealers focus as CarMax and Carvana converge?
Both companies are good at what they do, and each is now trying to get good at what the other does. Both are here to stay, and both are pushing the industry toward a better experience for consumers.
Financing is the biggest lever in this fight. As the old line goes, Carvana is a bank with the front of a car dealership, and CarMax is now leaning the same way. Recon is the second lever. CarMax is spending to get reconditioning out of the same bays that serve its customers. Two moves for every franchise store follow from that:
Know your lenders and lock in those relationships, so you can buy deeper and wider across credit tiers.
Keep frontline-ready recon from bottlenecking in the same pipeline as customer work, especially across a group.
You already have what CarMax is fighting to protect: the lot, the keys and the test drive. The open question is how you earn the attention of the shopper who's ready to buy if they can return it within seven days.
Watch Episode 1502 of the Automotive State of the Union for the full conversation.

