This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The 10-Second Version (AI Summary)

What happened: The New York City Council passed a bill banning pricing that uses personal data and algorithms to charge different people different prices for the same thing.

Why it matters: Shoppers are learning to ask whether their price reflects the product or a profile of them.

What to do: Make sure every customer would see the same price for the same car and the same product.

AI-generated summary, reviewed by the ASOTU team.

Would you trust a price if you knew it was built from your browsing history?

We broke this down on episode #1503 of the Automotive State of the Union podcast.

Picture two neighbors buying the same item on the same afternoon. One pays more because a company decided, based on where she lives and how she shops, that she would. The New York City Council just voted to stop that.

❝

"How much does the price reflect what's being sold, and how much does it reflect what a company thinks it can get out of you?"

Malwarebytes

What is surveillance pricing, and what does New York City's bill do?

What is it?
Using personal data such as location, browsing history, and shopping habits to set the price an individual sees. The FTC found tools that draw on details as small as mouse movements, with intermediaries serving at least 250 clients.

What does the bill do?
It bans the practice in consumer transactions in New York City and limits collecting, selling, or sharing personal data for that purpose.

When does it take effect?
The bill is on the mayor's desk. It would take effect one year after becoming law.

What's still allowed?
Qualifying loyalty programs and discounts for groups like veterans, seniors, and teachers, with conditions. Dynamic pricing based on demand or availability is a separate practice.

Does a personalized price always cost more?
No. These tools estimate what you're willing to pay, which can differ from what you can afford. Someone with an urgent need and few options could be judged willing to pay more.

Why should a car dealer care about a New York City pricing bill?

As far as we know, retail auto doesn't set prices with this kind of technology. The story still matters to every dealer.

This bill will have downstream effects well beyond New York, and it isn't going to struggle for public support. It fits a broader push from the FTC on transparency, so people can understand what they're getting at face value instead of after a series of tricks.

Customers are hyper-aware of pricing in every industry right now, from groceries to apparel to vehicles. Assuming shoppers don't follow these stories is a mistake.

Check whether two customers buying the same car on the same day would see the same advertised price, the same F&I menu, and the same add-ons. If the answer depends on who walked in, customers will eventually notice.

Watch Episode 1503 of the Automotive State of the Union for the full conversation on why this vote matters well beyond New York.